Witch hazel: the fiery ribbons of Kalmthout
In short: witch hazel is a shrub that flowers in the depths of winter, from December to March, with thin ribbon-like flowers in yellow, orange or red, often fragrant. The most widely planted varieties are hybrids (Hamamelis × intermedia) between a Chinese and a Japanese species, born from seed sown in 1928 at the Arnold Arboretum in Boston. Several of the finest, including 'Jelena' and 'Diane', come from the Kalmthout Arboretum near Antwerp, whose witch hazel collection is described as the largest in Europe. The shrub is hardy in Belgium (rated H5 by the RHS, down to −15 °C); it needs acid to neutral soil, moist but well drained, and almost no pruning. The one trap: most plants are grafted, and suckers from the rootstock must be removed.
In January, when the garden is nothing but bare branches and brown leaves, one shrub suddenly lights up with small flames. From a distance the flowers look like fireworks; up close, each one is just a handful of crumpled, ribbon-thin petals smelling of citrus or spice. This is witch hazel. We wanted to find out why it flowers out of season, where its varieties come from, and why the name of a village in the Antwerp Campine turns up on so many labels.
Five species, three continents
The genus Hamamelis has five species according to Kew's Plants of the World Online, three in North America and one each in China and Japan (Wikipedia, 2025, based on POWO):
| Species | Origin | Flowering | Garden role |
|---|---|---|---|
| H. virginiana | eastern North America | October-December | rootstock, witch hazel water |
| H. vernalis | Ozarks (central USA) | late winter | sometimes grown for its scent |
| H. ovalis | south-eastern USA | winter | rare in cultivation |
| H. mollis | central and western China | December-February | parent of the hybrids |
| H. japonica | Japan | late winter | parent of the hybrids |
They all share the same remarkable flower: four very narrow petals, up to 2 cm long and barely 2 mm wide (Bean, n.d.-a), clustered along the bare twigs. The fruits are woody capsules that stay on the shrub until the following winter, then split open suddenly and shoot out their seeds (Bean, n.d.-a). Early settlers in America used branches of H. virginiana as divining rods (Bean, n.d.-a), which may explain the English name witch hazel, echoed in the Dutch toverhazelaar.
The witch hazel water sold in pharmacies comes from the American species, H. virginiana. The witch hazels in our gardens are almost all Asian species or hybrids.
Petals that roll up when it freezes
How does such a delicate flower get through frosty nights? It does not resist; it folds up. When it is really cold, the petals roll up like paper ribbons; when the temperature rises, they unroll and open again (Arnold Arboretum, n.d.). The gardeners at Harvard's arboretum call them "botanical thermometers": one glance at a witch hazel tells you whether it is freezing.
This is what allows such a long flowering season: the shrub stays in flower for weeks, its flowers closed on cold nights and open on mild days. A very hard, prolonged frost can still damage some of them.
Practical consequence: do not cut a branch "because the flowers look dead" on a frosty morning. Wait for a milder afternoon before judging.
Flowering in winter: an almost losing bet
Flowering when hardly any insects are flying comes at a price. Botanists Gregory Anderson and Janet Hill, of the University of Connecticut, studied the reproduction of Hamamelis virginiana, the American species that flowers in autumn. Of more than 40,000 flowers examined, less than 1% produced a fruit in the wild (Anderson & Hill, 2002).
Their observations also correct a widespread idea. It is often said that witch hazel is pollinated by moths able to warm themselves up by shivering. Anderson and Hill mostly saw flies, especially small gnats of the genus Bradysia, and small bees, which carried a lot of witch hazel pollen; they consider wind pollination unlikely. The flowers are also self-incompatible: a plant's pollen does not fertilise its own flowers (Anderson & Hill, 2002).
Why take such a risk? A common but unproven explanation is the lack of competition: in winter, the few active insects have few other flowers to visit. In the garden, a witch hazel in bloom is a welcome resource for insects that venture out on a mild January day, hence its place near a sunny wall, where they are most likely to be about.
From Boston to Kalmthout: the birth of the hybrids
The Chinese witch hazel (H. mollis) was described in 1888 by the botanist Daniel Oliver, from specimens collected by Augustine Henry in Hubei province. But it was already in Europe without anyone knowing: in 1879, the plant hunter Charles Maries had sent seed to the Veitch nursery in England. The single plant raised grew unrecognised for nearly twenty years, until George Nicholson of Kew identified it around 1898 (Bean, n.d.-c). Ernest Wilson reintroduced it in 1907-1908 for the Arnold Arboretum in Boston. It flowers from December to February and, in England, is "often in full bloom on Christmas Day" (Bean, n.d.-c).
Boston is where everything changed. In 1928, the arboretum's propagator, William Judd, sowed seed collected from one of Wilson's Chinese witch hazels. The seedlings did not quite look like their mother. Nearly twenty years later, the taxonomist Alfred Rehder worked out why: a nearby Japanese witch hazel had supplied the pollen. He described the hybrid in 1945 as Hamamelis × intermedia, "intermediate" between its two parents (Bean, n.d.-b; Hetman, 2020).
One of these seedlings stood out in the late 1950s for its larger flowers and longer flowering: it was named 'Arnold Promise' in 1963 (Bean, n.d.-b). It flowers late, from mid-February into March, a trait inherited from its Japanese father (Hetman, 2020).
Kalmthout: a nursery, a couple, and witch hazels
Meanwhile, in the Antwerp Campine, another story had begun. In 1856, the nurseryman Charles Van Geert set up a tree plantation at Kalmthout; some forty years later he sold it to Antoine Kort (Wikipedia, n.d.-a). Kort was already collecting witch hazels by 1902 (Bean, n.d.-b). He sowed and selected, and in 1935 raised a copper-red hybrid, 'Ruby Glow' (Bean, n.d.-b). But the Depression of the 1930s ruined his nursery, which fell into decay (Wikipedia, n.d.-a; Bean, n.d.-b).
In 1952, the brothers Georges and Robert de Belder bought the estate (Wikipedia, n.d.-a). Two years later came Jelena Kovačič, born in 1925 in Jasenovac, Croatia, an agronomy graduate of the University of Zagreb. She had worked in Denmark and at the Lombarts nursery in Zundert, in the Netherlands; it was she who suggested propagating the witch hazels from cuttings. She married Robert de Belder a few months later (Wikipedia, n.d.-b).
In January 1955, a copper-coloured witch hazel from the seedlings left by Kort came into flower. Robert de Belder named it after his wife: 'Jelena'. Shown in London that same year, it received an award from the Royal Horticultural Society (Bean, n.d.-b; Wikipedia, n.d.-b). Its flowers are described as copper-orange from a distance, jasper red at the base of the petals and yellow ochre at the tips (Bean, n.d.-b). Then came 'Diane', named after the couple's daughter, a deep, uniform red, given an award by the RHS in 1969, and 'Primavera', primrose yellow (Bean, n.d.-b). Jelena de Belder went on to propagate some forty varieties at Kalmthout (Wikipedia, n.d.-b).
The Belgian connection goes further. 'Pallida', a pale yellow witch hazel very common in gardens, was raised at the RHS garden at Wisley from seed that may have come from Kort's nursery (Bean, n.d.-c).
The de Belders later moved to the Hemelrijk estate in Essen. In 1986, the province of Antwerp bought the arboretum (Wikipedia, n.d.-a). Robert died in 1995 and Jelena in 2003, after being made a baroness by King Albert II (Wikipedia, n.d.-b).
The largest collection in Europe
Today, the Kalmthout Arboretum covers 13.5 hectares and holds more than 11,000 kinds of plants (Arboretum Kalmthout, n.d.; Wikipedia, n.d.-a). Its witch hazel collection, with some 280 registered names in 2024, is described as the largest in Europe (Wikipedia, n.d.-a). You can see old shrubs planted in the de Belders' time, far larger than those in our gardens.
Every winter, the arboretum dedicates its season to the toverhazelaars. In 2027, the signposted route "De toverhazelaars bloeien" is planned from 2 January to 28 February, with a guided tour every day at 2 pm on booking; the arboretum is open every day from 10 am to 5 pm, except 25 December and 1 January (Arboretum Kalmthout, n.d.). It is the best way to choose a variety: you see it fully grown, you smell it, and you compare colours side by side.
Which variety should you choose?
All the varieties below have received the RHS Award of Garden Merit (AGM), which recognises plants that perform reliably in the garden (RHS, n.d.-c). According to the RHS, they reach 2.5 to 4 m tall and as wide at maturity, in 10 to 20 years for 'Jelena' (RHS, n.d.-a).
| Variety | Colour | Origin | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 'Jelena' | copper-orange | Kalmthout (Kort, named by the de Belders, 1955) | glows from a distance |
| 'Diane' | deep red | Kalmthout (R. de Belder, award 1969) | place against a light background |
| 'Arnold Promise' | clear yellow | Arnold Arboretum (1928 seedling, named 1963) | late flowering, February-March |
| 'Pallida' | pale yellow | Wisley (RHS), seed possibly from Kalmthout | visible from afar |
| 'Barmstedt Gold' | golden yellow | ||
| 'Vesna' | orange-yellow | December to March | |
| H. mollis 'Wisley Supreme' | yellow | Wisley (RHS) | Chinese witch hazel |
Two rules follow from this table. First, yellow varieties show up better in winter, from a distance and under a grey sky; red ones such as 'Diane' get lost against a dark background and need a light wall or open sky behind them. Second, scent varies from one variety to another, and catalogue descriptions do not always agree. If fragrance matters to you, smell the plant at the garden centre or at Kalmthout before buying.
One last, often forgotten criterion: autumn colour. 'Arnold Promise', for example, turns a clear, bright yellow before its leaves fall (Hetman, 2020); the shrub thus gives you two seasons.
Planting and growing witch hazel in Belgium
Witch hazel is hardy here: the RHS rates 'Jelena' H5, meaning hardy to frosts of −10 to −15 °C (RHS, n.d.-a). So the threat is not cold, but soil.
| Point | What you need to know |
|---|---|
| Soil | Acid to neutral, ideal pH 4.5 to 6.5; moist but well drained. It tolerates deep soil over chalk enriched with organic matter, not shallow chalky soil (RHS, n.d.-b). |
| Position | Sun or partial shade; in deep shade it becomes straggly and flowers poorly (RHS, n.d.-b). |
| Planting | October to April, avoiding frozen or waterlogged ground (RHS, n.d.-b). |
| Watering | For two to three years after planting; dry soil in summer or winter can make the buds drop (RHS, n.d.-b). |
| Mulch | Fallen leaves or compost at the base, to keep the soil moist. |
| Pruning | Unnecessary; let it grow freely (RHS, n.d.-b). Remove only dead wood or a badly placed branch, just after flowering. |
| Problems | Root rot (Phytophthora) in waterlogged soil, honey fungus, rabbits and deer, vine weevil in containers, powdery mildew (RHS, n.d.-b). |
Before buying, test your soil pH (a garden-centre kit is enough). On shallow chalky soil, as found on some rocky slopes in the south of the country, prepare a wide planting hole enriched with leaf mould, or choose another shrub.
The rootstock trap
Most witch hazels sold in garden centres are grafted onto the American species Hamamelis virginiana (RHS, n.d.-b). It makes sense: the Asian species graft easily onto it (Bean, n.d.-a), whereas their seed often takes two years to germinate and cuttings are tricky.
The rootstock has a mind of its own. It sometimes sends up suckers from the ground or below the graft union. These shoots carry leaves similar to the variety's, but keep them longer in autumn (RHS, n.d.-b); and since H. virginiana flowers from October to December, in yellow, they may give themselves away with out-of-season flowers. Left alone, they eventually smother the grafted variety.
What to do: as soon as you spot a sucker, cut it off as cleanly and as close to the main stem as you can, scraping away a little soil if necessary (RHS, n.d.-b). In November, a shoot that stays green while the rest of the shrub has dropped its leaves is a suspect.
Its winter companions
Witch hazel is not alone in flowering in winter. Around it, a few fragrant shrubs extend the season: winter viburnum (Viburnum × bodnantense), which we cover in our article on viburnums, wintersweet (Chimonanthus praecox), strongly scented, sarcococca, a small evergreen shrub for shade, and winter honeysuckle (Lonicera fragrantissima). At their feet, hellebores, to which we devote a full article, and the first snowdrops complete the picture.
Plant these shrubs near a path or a door: in winter, nobody wanders to the bottom of the garden, and a scent nobody smells is wasted.
True or false?
"Witch hazel flowers freeze at the first cold snap." False. The petals roll up when it freezes and unroll when the temperature rises; flowering goes on for weeks.
"Witch hazel is pollinated by moths." Not so simple. The most detailed study, on H. virginiana, mainly observed flies and small bees carrying pollen (Anderson & Hill, 2002). Moths may contribute, but they are not alone.
"A grafted witch hazel always stays true to its variety." False. The American rootstock can send up suckers which, if left to grow, end up dominating the shrub.
"Witch hazel grows anywhere." False. It dislikes shallow chalk and soils that are dry or waterlogged; a pH of 4.5 to 6.5 suits it best.
"It must be pruned every year to flower." False. The RHS advises letting it grow freely; hard pruning mainly removes the shoots that carry the flower buds.
Test yourself
Read also
Header photo: Hamamelis × intermedia 'Jelena' at the Kalmthout Arboretum, January 2026. Photo: WeeJeeVee, Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 4.0
Sources
Anderson, G. J., & Hill, J. D. (2002). Many to flower, few to fruit: the reproductive biology of Hamamelis virginiana (Hamamelidaceae). American Journal of Botany, 89(1), 67–78. https://doi.org/10.3732/ajb.89.1.67
Arboretum Kalmthout. (n.d.). De toverhazelaars bloeien; Zien en doen. https://www.arboretumkalmthout.be/nl/zien-en-doen
Arnold Arboretum. (n.d.). Botanical thermometers. Harvard University. https://arboretum.harvard.edu/stories/botanical-thermometers
Bean, W. J. (n.d.-a). Hamamelis. Trees and Shrubs Online. https://www.treesandshrubsonline.org/articles/hamamelis/
Bean, W. J. (n.d.-b). Hamamelis × intermedia. Trees and Shrubs Online. https://www.treesandshrubsonline.org/articles/hamamelis/hamamelis-x-intermedia/
Bean, W. J. (n.d.-c). Hamamelis mollis. Trees and Shrubs Online. https://www.treesandshrubsonline.org/articles/hamamelis/hamamelis-mollis/
Hetman, J. (2020, 4 March). The ultimate early bloomer. Arnold Arboretum of Harvard University. https://arboretum.harvard.edu/stories/the-ultimate-early-bloomer
RHS. (n.d.-a). Hamamelis × intermedia 'Jelena'. Royal Horticultural Society. https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/90268/hamamelis-%C3%97-intermedia-jelena/details
RHS. (n.d.-b). Witch hazel: growing guide. Royal Horticultural Society. https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/witch-hazel/growing-guide
RHS. (n.d.-c). Witch hazel (Hamamelis). Royal Horticultural Society. https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/witch-hazel
Wikipedia. (n.d.-a). Arboretum Kalmthout. https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arboretum_Kalmthout
Wikipedia. (n.d.-b). Jelena de Belder-Kovačič. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jelena_de_Belder-Kova%C4%8Di%C4%8D
Wikipedia. (2025). Hamamelis (species list based on Plants of the World Online, retrieved 27 October 2025). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamamelis