Lucky clover: it isn't a clover at all
In short: the "lucky clover" sold in pots for New Year is not a clover. It is Oxalis tetraphylla (often sold under its older name Oxalis deppei), a bulbous plant from Mexico whose leaves all naturally have four leaflets. The real four-leaf clover is an abnormal, rare white clover (Trifolium repens), whose genetics are only beginning to be understood. In Germany around 4.6 million pots are sold each year, grown in a few weeks from Dutch bulbs. Don't throw yours away in January: kept cool and bright, then planted outside in May, it flowers pink all summer and comes back every year. Its leaves contain oxalates: keep it out of reach of cats and dogs.
At the end of December, garden centres, supermarkets and florists line up little green pots topped with a chimney sweep, a pig or a horseshoe. People give them with their best wishes, they sit on the New Year's Eve table, then they turn yellow and end up in the bin by mid-January. A pity, because this plant has a richer story than its packaging suggests, and it lives for years. We looked into what this "clover" really is, where it comes from, who produces it and how to keep it.
Not a clover, but a Mexican oxalis
True clover belongs to the genus Trifolium, in the Fabaceae, the pea and bean family. "Lucky clover" belongs to the genus Oxalis, in an entirely different family, the Oxalidaceae. Its accepted name is Oxalis tetraphylla; the trade still often uses the synonym Oxalis deppei, and the Royal Horticultural Society (RHS) lists the best-selling cultivar as Oxalis tetraphylla 'Iron Cross' (RHS, n.d.).
The differences are obvious once you know where to look:
| Lucky clover | White clover | |
|---|---|---|
| Botanical name | Oxalis tetraphylla | Trifolium repens |
| Family | Oxalidaceae | Fabaceae (legumes) |
| Origin | Mexico | Europe, western Asia |
| Number of leaflets | 4, on every leaf | 3, very rarely 4 or more |
| Leaflet shape | inverted heart, fairly large | oval, small, often with a white V mark |
| Marking | purple-brown at the base, forming a cross | none, or a pale V |
| Flowers | pink, funnel-shaped, five petals | small round white heads |
| Underground organ | bulb and bulblets | creeping stems that root |
The dark blotch in the centre of the leaf explains the cultivar name 'Iron Cross': seen from above, it forms a cross. The plant grows 10 to 30 cm tall and flowers outdoors from late spring to late summer, in bright pink (RHS, n.d.).
In its homeland the species grows in annual herb communities and is divided into three geographical varieties: tetraphylla, mexicana and guerreroensis (Buch & Steinecke, 2014). It has naturalised in warmer parts of Africa, Australia, North America and southern Europe, and Buch and Steinecke report it as invasive in Japan. In central Europe, garden escapes remain rare and do not persist (Buch & Steinecke, 2014).
Cavanilles, Deppe and Loddiges: one plant, two names
The species was described in 1796 by the Spanish botanist Antonio José Cavanilles, director of the Royal Botanical Garden in Madrid, as Oxalis tetraphylla, literally "four-leaved oxalis" (IPNI, n.d.). The reference specimen came from the great Spanish expeditions to New Spain at the end of the 18th century.
In the 1820s the Prussian naturalist Ferdinand Deppe travelled through Mexico and brought bulbs back to Europe. In 1829 the London nurseryman George Loddiges published it in his Botanical Cabinet (plate 1500) under a new name, Oxalis deppei, in honour of the traveller (IPNI, n.d.). The two names coexisted for a long time; today the rule of priority favours the older one, O. tetraphylla, and O. deppei is merely a synonym. According to Buch and Steinecke (2014), the species was introduced to England as an ornamental in 1839.
The genus name is older than the plant. Oxalis comes from the Greek oxys, "sour": the Ancients used it for sorrel, because of its tart taste. Linnaeus transferred the name to the present genus, which shares that flavour. Oxalic acid, isolated later, in turn takes its name from the genus (Buch & Steinecke, 2014).
The real four-leaf clover: a matter of genes and weather
If oxalis has replaced clover in New Year pots, it is because the real four-leaf clover is rare and fickle. In white clover, leaves with four or more leaflets reportedly appear on about 0.1 to 1% of plants, according to a German popular book cited by Buch and Steinecke (2014). The often-repeated figure of "one in 10,000", quoted for example by Inside Science magazine (Gammon, 2017), is not based on any study we could trace. In reality the frequency varies enormously from one meadow to the next, because the trait is both genetic and environmental.
In 2010 Wayne Parrott's team at the University of Georgia published the first molecular mapping of a gene linked to leaflet number in white clover (Tashiro et al., 2010). Their findings:
- white clover is an allotetraploid species (four sets of chromosomes from two ancestral species) and highly heterozygous, which had defeated all classical genetic studies;
- the "multifoliolate" trait (more than three leaflets) is controlled by one or more recessive genes, and its expression is strongly influenced by the environment;
- a dominant gene that maintains three leaflets was located on linkage group H1, but not identified;
- its position on the map differed depending on whether the plants were scored in summer or in winter.
The researchers point out a delightful detail: the most primitive species of the genus Trifolium often have five leaflets. Clover is thought to descend from ancestors with multiple leaflets, and the three-leaved clover would be the result of a gene that suppressed some. The four-leaf clover would therefore not be a novelty but a throwback (Tashiro et al., 2010).
The practical consequence: since the trait is partly genetic, a clump of white clover that has produced one four-leaf leaf is more likely than another to produce more. If you find one, go back and check the same clump.
Shamrock, clover and oxalis: which is which?
Ireland has its own symbolic clover, the shamrock, worn on St Patrick's Day. Which plant is it? In 1893 the naturalist Nathaniel Colgan asked correspondents throughout the island to send him "the true shamrock". The botanist Charles Nelson repeated the survey in 1988 (Colgan, 1893; Nelson, 1991).
| Plant sent | 1893 | 1988 |
|---|---|---|
| Lesser trefoil (Trifolium dubium) | 51% | 46% |
| White clover (Trifolium repens) | 34% | 35% |
| Black medick (Medicago lupulina) | 6% | 7% |
| Red clover (Trifolium pratense) | 6% | 4% |
| Wood sorrel (Oxalis acetosella) | – | 3% |
| Various (Trifolium, Oxalis) | 3% | 5% |
Figures taken from the Wikipedia summary ("Shamrock"), after Colgan (1893) and Nelson (1991); we have not consulted Nelson's book.
A century later the answer had barely changed: the shamrock is above all lesser trefoil, and an oxalis for only a few per cent of the Irish. Wood sorrel also grows in Belgium, in cool woodland: three heart-shaped leaflets, white flowers veined with pink in spring.
As for the power of the four-leaf clover, it is old. In the Middle Ages it was believed to reveal witches, protect against evil spells and bring luck in love (Buch & Steinecke, 2014). The four-leaved oxalis in a pot has inherited the symbol without the rarity. We found no reliable source dating the start of the tradition of giving an oxalis at New Year.
Millions of pots for a single night
The only public figures we found are German. There, the market research firm AMI (Agrarmarkt Informations-Gesellschaft) estimated average sales at 4.6 million pots a year, with consumers spending up to 8.5 million euros (Gartenfreunde, 2018). The figure dates from 2018; we found nothing more recent.
Production is highly concentrated. At the end of 2017 grower Matthias Christoph, based since 2000 in Halte (municipality of Weener, East Frisia, near the Dutch border), produced around 1.3 million plants a year on his own; Germany then had only four specialist businesses (Connemann, 2017). At the end of 2022 the same nursery was still shipping its pots all over Germany, to Hungary, Bulgaria and Switzerland (NWZ, 2022).
The key link is Dutch: "we get the clover as bulbs from Holland", the grower explains (NWZ, 2022). The dependence is strong: in the year before the 2017 article, a fire at a Dutch bulb grower had cut the supply of lucky clover to about 20% of normal (Connemann, 2017). In the Netherlands, businesses such as Lommerse-Bood, which specialises in oxalis (some 80 species and selections), grow the bulbs and sell them dry, mainly for export, from mid-July to late August (Lommerse-Bood, n.d.).
The growing schedule is short:
- October: the bulbs are planted in 6 to 13 cm pots;
- October to December: the plants grow under glass at 8 to 14 °C (NWZ, 2022), with artificial lighting to make up for our short days (IVA, 2023);
- 25 to 27 December: wholesalers collect most of the crop (Connemann, 2017). About half the pots get a little chimney sweep, placed by hand.
Sales are concentrated in a few days: after 1 January demand collapses (NWZ, 2022). It is the most "short-lived" product in the garden centre, while the plant itself is a perennial.
Choosing it and keeping it through January
An oxalis forced under glass for December reaches your home in difficult conditions: little light, heating, dry air. A few simple steps will keep it looking good until spring.
| Point | What to do |
|---|---|
| When buying | Plenty of bright green leaves, no yellowing or mould at the base; compost neither soaking wet nor dry. |
| Position | As bright as possible, in front of a window; away from radiators. |
| Temperature | Ideally 10 to 18 °C (IVA, 2023): a cool bedroom or frost-free conservatory is better than a living room at 22 °C. |
| Watering | Moderate: when the surface of the compost is dry, never any water in the saucer (Gartenfreunde, 2018). |
| Feeding | Unnecessary in winter. |
| Pot | Remove the decorative sleeve or empty it after each watering. |
If the stems stretch and flop, the plant is short of light: common in a Belgian January. It doesn't matter; the plant will grow new leaves once outside.
Oxalis leaves fold downwards at night and in strong light: these are "sleep movements", driven by small joints at the base of the leaflets. According to Buch and Steinecke (2014), they reduce water loss by bringing together the undersides of the leaflets, where the stomata are. A plant with folded leaves in the evening is neither sick nor thirsty.
After the holidays: keeping it for years
The four-leaved oxalis is a bulbous perennial. With a simple cycle, it comes back every year and multiplies by itself through its bulblets (Buch, 2015).

Flowers of four-leaved oxalis (Oxalis tetraphylla), in summer. Photo: Wildfeuer, Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 3.0
| Period | What to do |
|---|---|
| January to April | Cool and bright, moderate watering. The leaves may gradually yellow: this is normal. |
| April | Unpot, separate the bulbs and bulblets, replant them in fresh compost about 5 cm deep, 15 to 20 cm apart (IVA, 2023). |
| Mid-May, after the Ice Saints | Put the pots outside or plant in the garden, in sun or part shade. Water regularly in summer, liquid feed every two weeks (Buch, 2015). |
| June to August | Pink flowers. Watch out for slugs, which love the leaves (RHS, n.d.). |
| October-November | The leaves turn yellow: stop watering. |
| Winter | Bring pots into a cool, frost-free cellar or garage (5 to 10 °C), without watering (Gartenfreunde, 2018). In the garden, lift the bulbs and store them dry. |
Opinions differ on hardiness. The RHS rates 'Iron Cross' H4, meaning it withstands frosts of −5 to −10 °C (RHS, n.d.), but the German sources all advise keeping it frost-free. In Belgium, where winters are often cold and wet, we recommend caution: a bulb in waterlogged, frozen soil risks rotting. Bring it in.
Want leaves for next New Year? Growers manage it with lit greenhouses. At home, bulbs repotted in October and placed in front of a very bright window at 8 to 14 °C may produce leaves in December, but there is no guarantee: the first leaves appear six to eight weeks after planting (IVA, 2023).
Toxic to cats and dogs?
Like other oxalis, the plant contains oxalic acid and oxalates. The ASPCA, the American animal poison control centre, lists the whole Oxalis genus as toxic to dogs, cats and horses. Possible signs: salivation, tremors and, rarely in dogs and cats, kidney damage (ASPCA, n.d.).
For humans, Buch and Steinecke (2014) describe all parts of the plant as "slightly toxic". The leaves have a tart, sorrel-like taste; our native wood sorrel is in fact eaten in small amounts in salads. But oxalic acid interferes with calcium absorption and can promote kidney stones in susceptible people: lucky clover is an ornamental, not a salad.
True or false?
"Lucky clover is a clover bred to have four leaves." False. It is a Mexican oxalis, Oxalis tetraphylla, from another family. Its four leaflets are natural and present on every leaf.
"You should throw it away when it turns yellow." False. Yellowing often signals the bulb going dormant. Rested and then replanted in spring, it regrows and flowers in summer.
"The real four-leaf clover is just a random mutation." False, or at least incomplete. The trait depends on recessive genes and the environment: the same plant may produce four-leaf leaves in summer and not in winter (Tashiro et al., 2010).
"The Irish shamrock is an oxalis." Mostly false. In the 1893 and 1988 surveys, most Irish people sent lesser trefoil or white clover; oxalis accounted for only a few per cent of responses.
"Leaves that close in the evening are a sign of a sick plant." False. These are normal sleep movements in oxalis.
Test yourself
Read also
- Christmas plants: 15 myths checked
- Poinsettia: choosing, keeping and reblooming
- January in the garden
Sources
ASPCA. (n.d.). Shamrock plant. ASPCA Animal Poison Control. https://www.aspca.org/pet-care/animal-poison-control/toxic-and-non-toxic-plants/shamrock-plant
Buch, C. (2015). Oxalis deppei, Glücksklee für die Fensterbank. Der Palmengarten. https://ojs.ub.uni-frankfurt.de/Palmengarten/index.php/Palmengarten/article/download/202/177/348
Buch, C., & Steinecke, H. (2014). Oxalis deppei – Glücksklee (Oxalidaceae). Jahrbuch des Bochumer Botanischen Vereins, 5, 232–235. https://www.botanik-bochum.de/jahrbuch/Pflanzenportraet_Oxalis_deppei.pdf
Colgan, N. (1893). The shamrock: a further attempt to fix its species. The Irish Naturalist, 2(8), 207–211.
Connemann, G. (2017, 26 December). 1,3 Millionen Mal Glück. https://gitta-connemann.de/13-millionen-mal-glueck/
Gammon, K. (2017, 16 March). Shamrock science: St. Patrick's Day symbol versus the four-leaf clover. Inside Science. https://www.aip.org/inside-science/shamrock-science-st-patricks-day-symbol-versus-the-four-leaf-clover
Gartenfreunde. (2018, 21 December). Millionenfach Glücksklee. Verlag W. Wächter. https://www.gartenfreunde.de/gartenpraxis/gut-zu-wissen/millionenfach-gluecksklee/
IPNI. (n.d.). Oxalis tetraphylla Cav.; Oxalis deppei G.Lodd. International Plant Names Index. https://www.ipni.org
IVA. (2023, 19 December). Glück mit Glücksklee? Industrieverband Agrar. https://www.iva.de/iva-magazin/umwelt-verbraucher/glueck-mit-gluecksklee
Lommerse-Bood. (n.d.). Onze Oxalis kwekerij. https://lommerse-bood.nl/kwekerij.php
Nelson, E. C. (1991). Shamrock: Botany and history of an Irish myth. Boethius Press.
NWZ. (2022, 28 December). Glücksklee zu Silvester: Grüne Glücksbringer aus Weener für ganz Deutschland. Nordwest-Zeitung. https://www.nwzonline.de/landkreis-leer/gluecksklee-zu-silvester-gruene-gluecksbringer-aus-weener-fuer-ganz-deutschland_a_51,11,3049082278.html
RHS. (n.d.). Oxalis tetraphylla 'Iron Cross'. Royal Horticultural Society. https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/48100/oxalis-tetraphylla-iron-cross/details
Tashiro, R. M., Han, Y., Monteros, M. J., Bouton, J. H., & Parrott, W. A. (2010). Leaf trait coloration in white clover and molecular mapping of the red midrib and leaflet number traits. Crop Science, 50(4), 1260–1268. https://doi.org/10.2135/cropsci2009.08.0457