Bare-root fruit trees: choosing well

Bare-root fruit trees: choosing well

In short: an apple tree bought bare-root this winter will still be there in fifty years. Three choices decide almost everything. The rootstock sets the size of the tree and the age of its first fruit: from 1.5 m on M27 to over 4.5 m on M25, according to the Royal Horticultural Society (RHS). The variety decides the tree's health: since 1975, the Walloon Agricultural Research Centre (CRA-W) in Gembloux has been testing old varieties in orchards that are never sprayed, and has put 33 of them back on the market under the name "RGF-Gblx". Pollination: most apple and pear trees need a neighbour that flowers at the same time. In the provinces of Namur and Hainaut, the directory at the end of the article shows the nurseries nearest to you.

Updated on 18 November 2026.

November opens the bare-root season, and nurseries bring out their fruit trees. The planting itself is covered in detail in November in the garden: a wide rather than deep hole, roots never left in the wind, stake in place before backfilling. This article deals with what happens before that, when you read the label. A wrong choice cannot be undone: a tree too vigorous for the garden, a variety that needs spraying every year, or a lone apple tree that flowers but never fruits.

Two trees in one: rootstock and variety

A fruit tree from the garden centre is almost never a tree "as is". It is two plants joined together: a variety (Reinette Dubois, Durondeau, Conference…) grafted onto a rootstock, which provides the roots. The variety decides the fruit, the flowering and, to a large extent, disease resistance. The rootstock decides the final size of the tree, the age at which it starts to crop, the soil it tolerates and whether it needs a stake for life.

You cannot sow an apple pip and get the same apple: a pip is the result of a cross, and the tree it produces is a new variety, almost always worse than its parents. That is why fruit trees are grafted. The graft union is visible on the trunk, a few centimetres above the roots: a distinct bulge. At planting, it must stay well above the soil, the RHS reminds us (RHS, n.d.-a). If buried, the variety would root on its own and the effect of the rootstock would be lost.

The most common apple rootstocks carry English code names: "M" for East Malling, the research station in Kent that selected them, "MM" for the Malling-Merton series, bred with the John Innes Institute at Merton. The label of a good fruit tree always gives them. If it says nothing, ask: a seller who does not know what the tree is grafted on does not know how big it will grow either.

Apples: from a 1.5 m cordon to an orchard tree

The RHS ranks apple rootstocks from the most dwarfing to the most vigorous (RHS, n.d.-d). Heights are for a tree grown as a bush; poor or dry soil reduces them.

Rootstock Vigour Height × spread First fruit Stake For which garden
M27 Extremely dwarfing 1.2-1.8 m × 1.5 m after 2 years For life Cordons, containers, very small gardens with fertile soil
M9 Dwarfing 1.8-2.4 m × 2.7 m after 2-3 years For life Small gardens, spindlebush, cordons
M26 Dwarfing 2.4-3 m × 3.6 m after 2-3 years For life Medium gardens, espaliers, average soils
MM106 Semi-dwarfing 3-4 m × 4 m after 3-4 years 5 years (longer on exposed sites) Varied soils, even poor; too big for a small garden
MM111 Vigorous 4-4.5 m × 4.5 m after 4-5 years 3 years for a 2-3-year-old tree Half-standards and standards, grassed orchards
M25 Very vigorous over 4.5 m × 6 m after 5-6 years 3 years for a 2-3-year-old tree Standards, grassed orchards

Source: RHS (n.d.-d), "Rootstocks for fruit".

Two practical consequences. First, a dwarfing rootstock is not an easy rootstock: M27 and M9 have weak root systems, hence the permanent stake, and the RHS asks for fertile soil, kept free of weeds and grass around the base and watered in dry spells. In a lawn or poor soil, they struggle. Second, the more vigorous the tree, the more self-sufficient it is: the RHS considers MM111 and M25 suitable for most soils, including poor and grassed ones. They still need watering in dry weather during the first years, and grass should be kept clear of the base. In return, you wait four to six years for the first apples, and need a ladder to pick them.

The CRA-W itself grafts its evaluation apple trees on M9 and, more recently, on an American rootstock from the Geneva series, G11 (Dumont et al., 2025). That is a researcher's choice, wanting quick fruit and closely planted trees, not a recommendation for an amateur orchard.

Pears, plums and cherries: fewer options, same principles

Species Rootstock Vigour Height First fruit Soil (RHS)
Pear Quince C Dwarfing 2.5-3 m after 4 years Fertile, moisture-retentive
Pear Quince A Semi-vigorous 3-4.5 m after 4 years Most medium to heavy fertile soils
Plum Pixy Semi-dwarfing 3-4 m 3-4 years Light, loamy
Plum St Julien A Semi-vigorous 4.5-5 m after 3-4 years Tolerates heavy soils
Cherry Gisela 5 Semi-dwarfing 2.4-3 m 3-4 years Fertile, loamy; permanent stake
Cherry Colt Semi-vigorous 6 m after 3-4 years Tolerates clay and light chalky soils

Source: RHS (n.d.-d), "Rootstocks for fruit".

Pears have a peculiarity that catalogues often keep quiet about. Grafted on quince, a pear tree is smaller and crops earlier than on pear seedling rootstock, but many varieties do not "take" well on quince. At the CRA-W, the problem used to be solved with an interstock: a piece of Beurré Hardy grafted on Quince A, then the desired variety grafted onto that Beurré Hardy. For about ten years now, the centre has been switching to the Pyrodwarf rootstock: according to its researchers, it is about 20% more vigorous than Quince A, quick to crop and, above all, compatible with all pear varieties (Dumont et al., 2025). If you buy an old pear variety, ask what it is grafted on, and whether an interstock was used.

For its plums and cherries, the same centre uses St Julien A and Gisela 5 (Dumont et al., 2025), two rootstocks easy to find at Belgian nurseries.

Bush, half-standard, standard: form follows rootstock

Nurseries also sell forms, which depend on the rootstock and the height at which the branches start:

  • cordon, spindlebush, bush: on a dwarfing rootstock, for small gardens, along a wall or a fence;
  • half-standard: on a medium or vigorous rootstock, the compromise for a family garden;
  • standard: the big tree of grassed orchards, under which grass is mown or grazed. It needs a vigorous rootstock. For half-standard and standard orchards of old varieties, Marc Lateur of the CRA-W recommends 12 to 15 metres between trees (Lateur, 2013).

A simple rule: measure the space. An MM106 fills a circle 4 m across, an M25 a circle 6 m across. A fruit tree planted too close to a house or a boundary gets cut back every year against its nature, and mostly produces wood.

Orchard planting can be subsidised: Wallonia pays 25 € per tree for orchards, under the same scheme as hedges. Details are in our article November in the garden.

Gembloux, 1975: rescuing the old varieties

The story begins with a plant pathologist's observation. In 1975, at the State Plant Pathology Station in Gembloux, Charles Populer noticed that almost all apple and pear trees sold by nurseries were highly susceptible to scab, and that their genetic diversity was narrow. His idea: seek out the varieties grown before modern fungicides, and even before Bordeaux mixture in the late 19th century, since they had to survive without protection (Dumont et al., 2025).

In the first years, the team visited ten historical horticultural collections, five in Flanders, four in Wallonia and one in Brussels, and brought back 620 pear and 580 apple accessions. An unexpected effect, the researchers recount: several managers of those collections then dismantled them, since "everything is safe in Gembloux". Then the press, radio and television took up the story. Between 1980 and 1987, more than 2,000 people contacted the centre to report old trees under threat in their gardens or meadows. The collection reached 2,181 accessions in 1987, then 2,526 in 1997 (Dumont et al., 2025).

Today, the CRA-W keeps 1,629 apple, 1,198 pear, 355 cherry, 236 plum, 98 table grape and 29 peach accessions, plus native wild apples and pears. Every year, the public still sends in 300 to 900 fruit samples for identification (Dumont et al., 2025). What makes Gembloux special: its evaluation orchards are never sprayed against diseases or pests, and chemical weeding at the foot of the trees was abandoned in 2000. For a large share of the varieties, the centre has more than 25 years of observations without protection.

RGF-Gblx varieties: 33 survivors, tested ten years without spraying

From this collection, the CRA-W has drawn a range for gardeners and farmers: the "RGF-Gblx" varieties, for Ressources Génétiques Fruitières de Gembloux (Gembloux fruit genetic resources). Most are old local varieties, often landraces or selections by 19th-century amateur breeders, that had disappeared from the market. Each was evaluated for at least ten years in unsprayed orchards: tolerance to diseases, pests and weather, fruit quality and uses, behaviour on different rootstocks (Dumont et al., 2025).

The range now includes 18 apples, 7 pears, 4 plums, 3 cherries and 1 peach. A 2013 CRA-W sheet lists among the RGF-Gblx apples: Transparente de Lesdain, Reinette Evagil, Grenadier, Président Roulin, La Paix, Cwastresse Double, Reinette de Blenheim, Radoux, Joseph Musch, Reinette Hernaut, Gris Braibant, Godivert, Reinette de Waleffe, Reinette Dubois and Président Van Dievoet (Lateur, 2013). For each one, the sheet gives the picking season, flowering group, pollen quality, susceptibility to scab, powdery mildew and canker, and uses: dessert, cooking, juice or cider.

One detail matters to the buyer. The name of an old variety guarantees nothing: synonyms and mislabelling are common, even in collections (Dumont et al., 2025). For that reason, the CRA-W and a group of volunteer nurserymen created the Certifruit charter. It guarantees the origin and identity of the material (variety, rootstock and any interstock), the quality of the young trees and local, small-scale production. The budwood comes from a 3.3 ha mother plantation set up in 1991 at Ormeignies, managed by the Centre d'Essais Horticoles de Wallonie; about half of the RGF-Gblx varieties there are certified "virus tested" (Dumont et al., 2025).

Scab: why "multi-gene" resistance lasts longer

Apple scab, caused by the fungus Venturia inaequalis, spots the leaves and cracks the fruit. It is the disease behind most orchard spraying, and the one that drove the whole Gembloux programme.

An apple tree can resist it in two main ways. The first relies on a single major gene, such as Rvi6 (long known as Vf), found in many modern so-called "resistant" varieties: the effect is spectacular, but a single lock can be picked by a new strain of the fungus. The second relies on several genes with partial effects ("polygenic" resistance): the tree gets a few spots, without serious damage. CRA-W researchers clearly favour this second route, "certainly" more durable, and cite Reinette Dubois and La Bazadaise as examples; Transparente de Lesdain combines both types of resistance (Rondia et al., 2025).

These observations come from an evaluation orchard managed organically since 2007, in a cross-border study with the Centre Régional de Ressources Génétiques at Villeneuve-d'Ascq, France: old varieties are compared with Jonagold, the most widely grown apple in Belgium. Gris Braibant, Président Van Dievoet and La Bazadaise also show very low susceptibility there to apple anthracnose (Elsinoë pyri), a disease of growing concern for organic orchards in the region (Rondia et al., 2025).

The CRA-W also breeds new varieties, crossing modern apples with old local ones. The most recent, Ducasse, comes from Reinette Libotte and Rubinola, and is protected by a European plant variety right (Dumont et al., 2025). It is aimed mainly at professional organic growers.

Pollination: a lone apple tree flowers in vain

Most apple and pear trees cannot fertilise themselves: they need pollen from another variety flowering at the same time. The RHS therefore sorts varieties into numbered pollination groups. The rule: choose a pollinator from the same group or a neighbouring one, whose flowering overlaps. An apple in group 3, the most common, can be pollinated by groups 2, 3 or 4 (RHS, n.d.-b).

The CRA-W uses the same principle, with groups from 1 (very early) to 7 (very late), and adds a second criterion: the pollen quality of each variety. A good pollinator flowers at most one class before or after the variety to be fertilised, and has good pollen (Lateur, 2013).

The triploid trap. Some varieties have three sets of chromosomes instead of two: they bear fruit, but their pollen is almost sterile. The RHS lists Bramley's Seedling, Ribston Pippin, Holstein, Catillac and Blenheim Orange, known in Belgium as Reinette de Blenheim, an RGF-Gblx variety (RHS, n.d.-b). A triploid needs two other varieties, which pollinate each other and the triploid as well.

No room for two apple trees? A compatible apple tree in a neighbouring garden may be enough: bees carry the pollen. The RHS also points out that crab apples (small-fruited Malus) are excellent pollinators, with abundant flowers over a long period (RHS, n.d.-b).

When Belgium invented pears

If you plant a pear tree, you are probably planting a bit of Belgian history. In the 18th and 19th centuries, our regions were the great laboratory of the dessert pear.

  • Nicolas Hardenpont (born 1705), an abbot in Mons, sowed pips in his garden at the foot of Mont Panisel for some thirty years. He raised about a dozen "butter" pears with very melting flesh, including Beurré d'Hardenpont and Passe-Colmar (Cruysmans, 2015).
  • Jean-Baptiste Van Mons (1765-1842), a Brussels chemist who became a professor in Leuven, systematised the method: sow, re-sow, sow again, generation after generation. He is regarded as the most prolific pear breeder known, with at least 40 worthwhile varieties; Beurré Bosc and D'Anjou are among those attributed to him. He sent scions and plants all over Europe and as far as the United States (Wikipedia, n.d.-b).
  • Charles-Louis Durondeau, a brewer at Tongre-Notre-Dame in Hainaut, raised the Durondeau pear, or Beurré Durondeau, in 1811: an October pear with very juicy flesh (Wageningen University & Research, n.d.).
  • Major Pierre-Joseph Esperen, in Mechelen, raised Joséphine de Malines, a winter pear, around 1830 (Pomologie.com, n.d.).

Conference, ubiquitous in Belgian orchards, does not belong to this line: it was raised in England by Rivers nursery in Sawbridgeworth, and owes its name to the National Pear Conference in London in 1885, where it won first prize (Wikipedia, n.d.-a).

Buying and planting: good habits

At the nursery, check four things:

  1. The label: variety, rootstock and, for an old pear, any interstock. For an RGF-Gblx variety, the Certifruit label guarantees identity.
  2. The graft union: neat, well healed, with no rot and no suckers from the rootstock.
  3. The roots: plentiful, fresh, never dry or brittle.
  4. The age: a one-year-old maiden (a single stem) can be trained as you wish and establishes very well; a two- or three-year-old tree crops sooner but needs a stake for longer.

At planting, the RHS advises soaking the roots for about 30 minutes (RHS, n.d.-e), keeping the graft union well above the soil (RHS, n.d.-a), and putting the stake in at the same time as the tree: at 45°, top facing the prevailing wind, with a gap of no more than 2.5 cm between trunk and stake. It usually stays in place for eighteen months to three years, longer on a weak rootstock (RHS, n.d.-c). The full step-by-step guide is in November in the garden. For winter pruning of established apple and pear trees, see December in the garden.

For advice, the Diversifruits association, founded in 2018 by the CRA-W and the Federation of Walloon Nature Parks, has about 150 members and organises some 70 activities a year. It helps with choosing varieties and managing orchards; more than 500 ha of grassed orchards have been planted with its support in ten years (Dumont et al., 2025).

Before buying a fruit tree, always ask what rootstock it is grafted on. That, not the variety, decides whether the tree will be 2 m or 6 m tall.

True or false?

"A dwarf apple tree is easier to grow." Partly false. It is easier to prune and pick, but the dwarfing rootstocks M27 and M9 have weak roots: a stake for life, fertile soil, weeded and watered in summer, according to the RHS. In poor soil or in a lawn, an MM106 or MM111 does better.

"Old varieties are all disease-resistant." False. Many old varieties are as susceptible as modern ones. What makes RGF-Gblx varieties interesting is that they were sorted after at least ten years of observation without spraying.

"A solitary apple tree bears no fruit." Mostly true, if no other apple tree flowers nearby. But neighbours count: an apple tree next door, or a crab apple, may be enough.

"Conference is a Belgian pear." False. It is English, awarded a prize in London in 1885. The great Belgian pears of the 19th century are called Durondeau, Joséphine de Malines, Beurré d'Hardenpont or Beurré Bosc.

"You can plant the pips of a good apple." True, but you will not get the same apple: each pip gives a new variety. That is exactly how Van Mons and Hardenpont created theirs, sowing pips generation after generation and keeping only the best trees.

What mainly determines the final size of a grafted apple tree?

Show the answer

Answer: The rootstock

The rootstock sets the vigour: according to the RHS, an apple on M27 stays under 1.8 m, while one on M25 exceeds 4.5 m.

What does RGF-Gblx mean on the label of a fruit tree?

Show the answer

Answer: An old variety selected by the CRA-W in Gembloux after at least ten years of trials without spraying

RGF stands for Ressources Génétiques Fruitières (fruit genetic resources). The CRA-W has put 33 back on the market, including 18 apples and 7 pears.

Why does a triploid apple tree such as Reinette de Blenheim need two other varieties nearby?

Show the answer

Answer: Because its pollen is almost sterile: it cannot pollinate its neighbours

The two other varieties must pollinate each other and the triploid, according to the RHS.

Sources

Cruysmans, M.-N. (2015, 21 February). Nicolas Hardenpont. La Libre Belgique. https://www.lalibre.be/archives-journal/2015/02/21/nicolas-hardenpont-62UYNDMZSRAQREWG6Z2726SCIU/

Dumont, B., Rondia, A., Delpierre, L., Dupont, P., Donis, T., Ferrier, V., Reyser, J., Jorion, A., Mingeot, D., Houben, P., Pennetreau, Y., Stievenard, R., Rey, J.-B., Bruneaux, G., Grifnée, A., Cerisier, B., Velghe, E., Mulot, E., Fauche, F., … Lateur, M. (2025). Safeguarding, evaluating and valorizing fruit tree genetic resources in Belgium: Insights from nearly half a century of unsprayed orchard management. Genetic Resources, (S2), 185-202. https://doi.org/10.46265/genresj.JWFV3378

Lateur, M. (2013). Aide au choix de variétés anciennes de pommes pour la plantation de vergers en demi-tige et haute-tige. Centre wallon de Recherches agronomiques. https://parc-naturel-gaume.be/wp-content/uploads/Choix_POMMES.pdf

Lateur, M., & Populer, C. (1996). RGF apple varieties distributed by the Gembloux Phytopathological Station. Fruit Belge, 64(459). https://www.cra.wallonie.be/fr/rgf-apple-varieties-distributed-by-the-gembloux-phytopathological-station-1996

Pomologie.com. (n.d.). Joséphine de Malines. https://pomologie.com/poire/poire1/fpoires/josephinedemalines/josephinedemalinesd.html

RHS. (n.d.-a). Apples and pears: starting an espalier. Royal Horticultural Society. https://www.rhs.org.uk/fruit/apples/starting-an-espalier

RHS. (n.d.-b). Fruit basics: fruit pollination. Royal Horticultural Society. https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/beginners-guide/fruit-basics/fruit-pollination

RHS. (n.d.-c). How to stake a tree. Royal Horticultural Society. https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/types/trees/how-to-stake-a-tree

RHS. (n.d.-d). Rootstocks for fruit. Royal Horticultural Society. https://www.rhs.org.uk/fruit/fruit-trees/rootstocks

RHS. (n.d.-e). Trees and shrubs: planting guide. Royal Horticultural Society. https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/types/trees/planting-trees-shrubs

Rondia, A., Dumont, B., Donis, T., Lateur, M., Rey, J.-B., Stievenard, R., & Bruneau, G. (2025). Étude de variétés de pommes mieux adaptées à l'agriculture biologique : une approche transfrontalière et participative. Itinéraires BIO, (80). https://orgprints.org/id/eprint/56075/1/BrochureA4_ItinerairesBIO80_WEB.pdf

Wageningen University & Research. (n.d.). Durondeau. Library, special collections. https://library.wur.nl/speccol/fruitvrij/onzeappels/Peren/Durondeau.htm

Wikipedia. (n.d.-a). Conference pear. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conference_pear

Wikipedia. (n.d.-b). Jean-Baptiste Van Mons. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Baptiste_Van_Mons

← Back to articles